What do you think?
Every now and then we will be running opinion polls below - so if you feel strongly please do take part. Please note that the views you submit are anonymous – the overall results will be shown on FT Business websites and may be used to spark debate at FT Business events or in FT Business magazines
Current Polls
Past Polls
Are you a pension fund considering a buyout?
Yes. We are looking at it now (67%) | No. We are not interested (0%) | We have looked into it out of interest, but no decision has been made (11%) | It is too expensive to consider (22%)
Should scheme trustees be required to pass exams before qualifying as a trustee?
Yes. This would ensure we have the right people making key decisions (33%) | No. This will put people off becoming trustees (43%) | No. Trustees are not expected to know as much as the experts (24%) | Unsure (0%)
Has the 2008 Budget been good news for pension funds?
Yes. Pension schemes and members will benefit (17%) | No.The Budget did not go far enough (56%) | I think UK pension funds are beyond help (28%)
Recent proposals by the ASB that the liability discount rate should change from the AA-rated bond yield to a risk-free rate for pension funds will:
Add further unnecessary pressure to DB schemes (19%) | Will result in more buy-outs (44%) | This will help improve transparency (19%) | Unsure (19%)
Should the government introduce a deferral period for Personal Accounts for employers contributing 6% or more?
Yes. This will encourage employers to continue running good schemes (25%) | No. The idea is that everyone starts saving immediately and this could give the wrong message (75%) | Unsure. There needs to be more consultation on this (0%)
Should Société Générale's executive chairman Daniel Bouton step down following the rogue trader scandal?
Yes (50%) | No (50%)
Should work and pensions secretary Peter Hain quit over allegations that he failed to declare more than £100,000 in donations?
Yes. No question about it. He broke the rules. (55%) | No. We have seen too many changes; the industry needs someone in place long enough to make a change (9%) | Unsure. Depends what the Parliamentary Standards Committee discovers (36%)
Has the UK Pensions Bill gone far enough to address the 2012 personal accounts concerns?
No. The government has missed out key issues (50%) | No. There have been too many unexpected surprises (12%) | Yes. The government has done a brilliant job (6%) | Don’t care. I think personal accounts will be dead by 2015 (31%)
Should the Myners principles be made compulsory?
Yes. It is the only way to ensure best practice (50%) | No. It would add more red tape to the pensions industry (25%) | Not sure. Maybe schemes just need help in understanding them (25%)
Was Shell's decision to take a pension holiday prudent?
No, holidays should be a thing of the past. (50%) | Yes, a sizeable surplus justifies it. (33%) | I don't know. (17%)
What to you think of the UK Pension Regulator's revised guidance on clearance?
It lacks clarity and could actually make life tougher for trustees (50%) | There are no real substantial changes to the way in which clearance works (0%) | Unsure (50%)
Are default options in defined contribution pension funds a waste of time?
Yes.The majority that opt for them are in the wrong option (75%) | No. Because it is there to help those that are undecided (12%) | Unsure. Members should seek advice and chose the right option (12%)
Should pension scheme trustees be paid?
Yes. It would make them more efficient (46%) | No. Trustees must not benefit from their role (46%) | Unsure (8%)
Should pension funds enter class actions?
Yes, as they have nothing to lose by doing so (25%) | No, they should concentrate on shareholder engagement instead (50%) | Unsure. There is a cost to all shareholders and high lawyer fees to consider (25%)
Is 130/30 the next big thing?
Yes. We are already looking at it (33%) | No. it is all hype (67%) | Don’t know about it (0%)
Should private equity's tax structure be changed?
Yes, they should pay higher taxes (50%) | No, it should remain the same (21%) | No, they should pay lower taxes (0%) | Unsure (29%)
Do you think Gordon Brown will make a difference to UK's pensions landscape?
Yes. He will be great (8%) | No. He could have made a difference when he was the chancellor (92%)
Is there a need for greater transparency from fund managers on their shareholder voting actions?
Yes. Disclosure is currently very poor (33%) | Yes. Although there is some, it is not enough (67%) | No. There is enough disclosure (0%)
Is the £3,600 contribution cap for proposed UK Personal Accounts fair?
Yes. It is a balanced compromise (0%) | No, it should have been a lot higher (22%) | No, it should have been lower (11%) | Don’t care. Personal Accounts are generally a bad idea (67%)
What should be the cap for UK’s proposed Personal Accounts?
£3,000 (27%) | £5,000 (20%) | There should be no annual cap (53%)
Do fund managers really understand the needs of their pension scheme clients as well as they should?
No. Not at all. (0%) | They could do a lot better (88%) | Yes. We all understand each other and everything is great (12%)
With Gordon Brown being confirmed as Tony Blair’s successor as the UK prime minister, what do you think his main aim in pensions should be?
Compensate everyone that lost their pension when their companies went bust (25%) | Compensate schemes for the losses they made when he scrapped ACT (0%) | Remove the inequality between public and private sector pensions (50%) | Nothing. There are bigger issues to worry about (25%)
Following Tony Blair’s announcement on his final departure date, how would you rate the UK government’s record on pensions since 1997?
Terrible. Pensions are still a big mess (57%) | Not bad. Some good progress has been made (29%) | Brilliant. Everything is perfect (14%)
Is the increasing M&A activity in the asset management market causing a problem for investor choice?
No - there are already too many managers in the market (40%) | Yes - the more competition the better (60%)
Is buy-out a good option for pension funds?
Yes. It is the best way to deal with liability risk (25%) | No. It is too expensive and trustees should not be looking at it (50%) | Unsure. There is currently no alternative to buy-out (25%)
In light of recent increased pressure on ethical investing, do you think pension funds should list all their stock holdings publicly?
Yes. All pension funds should be transparent about their holdings (14%) | No. This is the trustees’ business (0%) | Unsure – it can be hard to achieve the right balance between ethics and good investment choices (86%)
Is LDI a useful term for pension funds?
Yes (0%) | No. It needs more clarification (33%) | It means different things to different people and should be renamed or scrapped as a term (67%)
Should the Pensions Regulator and the PPF be merged into one body?
Yes. This will help simplify pensions regulation (38%) | No. This will not work (44%) | Not sure – there are good and bad points about this happening (19%)
Do you think infrastructure is the next big thing for pension funds?
Yes, and we are already looking at it investing in it (60%) | Possibly – depends on the circumstances of the scheme (20%) | No. Property is still stronger in the alternatives markets (20%) | No. It's just all media hype (0%)
In light of recent strike threats, should unions keep their nose out of corporate pensions issues?
Yes.They are trying to get involved in business decisions which they have little understanding of (45%) | Yes. There is too much striking and not enough negotiating (9%) | No. They are there to protect their members' rights (45%)
Do pension fund trustees understand complex investment issues?
No. There is a real need for trustee education (44%) | They only understand basic concepts, but have no idea about complex issues such as hedge funds (33%) | Yes. Most trustees are fully trained and able to make the right decision for their scheme (11%) | No, but trustees do not need to know much as they can rely on their consultants (11%)
What impact is the recent ECJ ruling against the UK government likely to have on the Pension Protection Fund (PPF)?
PPF is likely to go bust within a period of two years if full compensation is ordered by the UK High (60%) | The PPF will increase levies significantly to meet payments (20%) | The PPF is already in a strong position and will meet demands (20%)
What do you think of NAPF plans to give a good pension mark to occupational pension schemes, with the contribution level being the main criteria used?
A good idea, it will help employees realise what a good scheme is. (30%) | Not sure, I need to see more details on it before I can judge. (40%) | A combined 10% DC contribution rate is unrealistically high, so it won't work. (10%) | Will be interesting to see how public and private sector schemes compare. (10%) | Doesn't take into account factors such as employer solvency, which are vital. (10%)
Pension funds and property investment - do you think that REITs will have any effect on property allocations?
Yes, property is underweighted by most schemes (25%) | Yes, but only for overseas property allocations (25%) | Possibly, but Reits are more volatile than other property vehicles (0%) | No, property is sufficiently weighted by funds (0%) | No, property is so last year, infrastructure is the thing for 2007! (50%)
What is your reaction to the Pension Protection Fund's decision to increase its levy estimate to £675m for 2007/8 due to undercollection last year?
It shows the levy was deliberately set too low at the start (26%) | Undercollection will remain a problem as schemes improve their funding (11%) | It will make life even harder for underfunded schemes (11%) | It's a good move to reduce any danger of a PPF deficit (26%) | It's funny that they've announced it just before Christmas (26%)
What is your view of the clampdown on alternatively secured pensions (ASP) and the U-turn on pensions term assurance announced in the pre-Budget report?
Further evidence of inconsistent and arbitrary policy-making (55%) | The government is right to limit potential abuse of tax relief by the rich (9%) | Not relevant to most people, so not too bothered really (9%) | The phrase 'rearranging deckchairs on the Titantic' comes to mind (27%)
Following the news that the Pension Protection Fund has a £343m deficit, do you think:
This is only a minor, short-term issue and the PPF will be financially strong (36%) | This shows that PPF levies must rise sharply, to the detriment of solvent schemes (27%) | This shows the concept of the PPF is fatally flawed and doomed to disaster (23%) | This shows that the PPF needs to find a more creative accountant (14%)
Following the Stern review on the economics of climate change, do you think the fiduciary duty of pension scheme trustees is:
To invest regardless of the climate change impact of their investments (0%) | To take the climate change impact of investments into account, as a secondary issue (8%) | To put the climate change impact of their investments at the heart of their investment policies (42%) | To ascertain scheme members' views on this issue and then to act accordingly (50%)
Do you expect to introduce or increase hedge fund investments within the next three years?
Yes. We are already looking at it (38%) | Yes, but not as soon as within the next three years (38%) | Possibly, but we are unsure when (12%) | No. Hedge funds do not form part of our long term investment strategy (12%)
Will EU age discrimination legislation for pensions have a significant impact on employer-sponsored defined contribution plans?
Yes – employers may be forced to level down as a result (0%) | Yes, but not sure what the impact will be (33%) | Unsure – the draft regulations are unclear to say (33%) | No. Employers have had plenty of time to assess age discrimination and fix potential problems (33%)
Do you think it is right to offer scheme members a potentially substantial cash payment if they transfer out of a defined benefit scheme?
Yes, not a problem (31%) | Yes, but only if they have access to independent advice (15%) | No, a cash payment could cloud members' judgement (23%) | No, it looks like a bribe and is bad for the image of pensions (31%)
Given his track record on pensions, do you think that Gordon Brown should be the next UK prime minister?
Yes, his record on pensions is good (14%) | Yes, despite his record on pensions (7%) | No, because his record on pensions is awful (36%) | No, but for other reasons (43%)
Is the proposed National Pension Savings Scheme/ Personal Accounts a good idea?
Yes, it is a brilliant idea (25%) | Possibly, but it needs more thought (19%) | No. The government should scrap the idea (31%) | Whatever (25%)
Has pensions simplification helped your scheme?
Yes, everything is really simple now (21%) | Yes, things are a bit simpler (17%) | Possibly, it should help in the long run (38%) | No, it has created more work for no gain (25%)

